Taking the Folk out of Folksonomy
Sunday, July 10th, 2005I came across TagCloud a few days ago, but am just not getting around to blogging about it.
It purports to be an “automated Folksonomy tool.” More from them:
Essentially, TagCloud searches any number of RSS feeds you specify, extracts keywords from the content and lists them according to prevalence within the RSS feeds. Clicking on the tag’s link will display a list of all the article abstracts associated with that keyword.
TagCloud lets you create and manage clouds with content you are interested in, and let’s you publish them on your own website.
I don’t get where folksonomy comes in to play here. They have tags, yes, but a key characteristic of folksonomy is that it is collection of user created data. There’s no user creation here, all the tags they’re extracting are derived from the text itself by their algorithms.
Auto-tagging is not folkonomy. Jonas and I have been over this, remember? This post pretty much sums up my arguments against auto-tagging, though some the arguments presented there don’t apply to tagcloud, I’m not re-presenting the arguments, so just go read them there and figure out for yourself which ones apply.